seed starting wintersown

Wintersown – Variables – A Reader’s Questions – Nature’s Principles

I see a lot of slightly varying definitions for winter sown.  Basically it’s considered an outdoor germination method.  Seeds are sown into containers that are covered but vented.  Then they’re left outside to germinate whenever nature says the time is right.

What I really love about this method is that you can adapt it to almost anything you want to do and at almost anytime you want to do it.  I would go so far as to say there is no absolute right or wrong way, because most of how you will go about winter sown will depend on what you want to accomplish.

For example, you can use the same idea for sowing seed of cold weather crops or warm weather crops but how you go about it may vary slightly. Variations will be dictated by your knowledge of the plants, the principles of nature, and what your goal is. If you don’t yet have knowledge of the plants or principles of nature, then your good common sense will guide you.  And even if you are not 100% successful, you’ve still gained invaluable first hand information about what you should and shouldn’t do.

Questions from a Reader

I received an email yesterday from Erica, a reader in Indiana.

Erica has been gardening about 6 years and reading TMG for two years.  She has 3 little boys who love eating cherry tomatoes off the plants and feels sure that her kindergartener is the only one at “school” with a bowl of cherry tomatoes in his lunch every day when the tomatoes are in season.

She told me she almost always gardens in the spirit of experimenting. (What a great approach!  Because – when it comes right down to it, no matter how much we know or how long we’ve gardened, nature can always throw us a surprise ball.)

She wrote:
This is my first year of trying winter sowing. I am excited to already have some starts here in Indiana.

Forecast for this weekend is 74 and 81 as highs, 50 or so at night.

Is that too warm to leave the milk jug tops on? or should I just move them to the north side of the house and leave them in the shade until it gets back to regular April temperatures?  I would hate to roast the little things!

She also wrote: “…even though I didn’t do it exactly right… I planted (even the warm weather crops) into milk jugs in Jan/Feb and set them straight outside snow and freeze and all. I didn’t keep them inside until they sprouted (germinated). I love letting them decide when they are ready.”

Her results thus far:

After a bit more questioning, I learned that Erica had sown and now has seedlings of lettuce, broccoli, cabbage, sunflowers, poppies, dill, oregano and even a tomato!

Not surprisingly, the peppers, cilantro, celery, zinnia,  and holly hocks have not germinated. (Just too cold for them right now.)

She also had winter sown some peas and reports that they got moldy.


Peas don’t like to stay in cold damp ground a long time.  They tend to rot and of course, the mold is a step in that direction.

Peas are best direct sown in the spring, when the ground is or will warm soon.

Some gardeners like to soak the seed, roll in a paper towel, and presprout before planting.  I’ve done that and based on my experiences consider it pretty much a waste of time for me. Even my presprouted peas stay in the ground and don’t tend to show themselves anymore quickly than ones planted unsprouted.

Regarding Erica’s statement – “even though I didn’t do it exactly right” :

I think she did it just fine, because her purpose in the spirit of experimenting was to get seedlings earlier than what she would otherwise.  She accomplished that.  She also learned what crops will germinate earlier and what crops need warmer weather.

Question and Answers about Warm Daytime Temperatures

Back to her question about the forecast daytime temperatures of 74 to 81. (I don’t think the night time temperatures of 50 are anything to be concerned about.)

Although the jugs are vented, it could possibly get a bit hot inside when temperatures outside go to 74 or 81, especially when or if the jugs are in direct sunlight.

I’ve had winter sown crops stay in closed up jugs (caps off, of course) through warm temperatures and be just fine.  So it’s possible for the plants to go either way.

There are so many variables in situations like this that you almost have to just make a call based on every variable you know and your gut feeling and go with it.

What I’m Doing May Help You Decide What You Want to Do

I’ve written in detail about my variation of winter sown for starting warm weather crops. You may find it helpful to review it.

This year, because of the cool spring I sowed my tomato, pepper and eggplant seed in jugs on April 1, at bit later than usual. (I did not tape the jug halves together, but left them untaped.)

I was pressed for room on top of my washing machine (that’s where I put them to germinate) and we had a couple of warm days so I decided to mix things up a bit.

  • I moved 3 of the jugs with tomatoes outside under my makeshift coldframe.  Tops were on jugs as mentioned, but left unsealed.
  • The tomato seeds in the jugs outside germinated about the same time the tomato seeds inside germinated. (My peppers and eggplants have not yet germinated.)
  • After the tomato seed germinated I took the tops off the jugs, both those inside and outside.  At night, I put the cold frame back on the ones outside but left the jug tops off.

The Principles Behind the Decision

Everything needs air circulation.  Even when we sow in December, we leave the caps off the jugs so that air can get inside.  As temperatures warm we need more air in most cases.

All grown with a variation of the winter sown method.

All grown with a variation of the winter sown method.  (2012) Jugs at top right have tops attached, but are loose rather than taped.  Seed has not germinated in those jugs. (Caps always are off.)

Probably the most prevalent cause of damping off of seedlings is lack of air circulation. The other is over watering. (Damping off is the collapse and death of young seedlings as a result of a fungal infection.)

In all the years I’ve grown from seed, I’ve never experienced damping off of any seedlings.  And I never want to.  So I try to make sure that after germination of warm weather crops in particular, I give them plenty of air and plenty of sunlight.  Removing the tops insures they’ll get air.  Putting them outside insures they’ll get sun.  And the extra bonus is, they’re hardened off just about from day one.

Of course, I would not put tomato (or pepper or eggplant) seedlings  out without protection of the jug top and/or the coldframe if the wind is blowing like crazy or if the temperatures drop into the low 40s or below.  That would be way too stressful for those little seedlings. Even older tomato plants don’t like temperature in the 40s. They’ll live, they just don’t like it and will show you in one way or the other: decreased vigor or leaves turning purple.

Even my beets, lettuces, various green, onions, leeks, turnips that I started via winter sown, now have the tops of the jugs on – but loose. The only reason I’ve not taken them off completely is because we’re due for another cold snap with temperatures in the low 30s.  They could live through that easily, but  I’m still leaving the tops on until that’s past.

A Best Guess for Erica

I don’t know enough about Erica’s situation and the variables that exist there to tell her what to do, but my best guess would lean towards giving them more air in the warm temperatures by loosening the tops. (Her inner sense told her that already, which is why she asked the question.)

I would also lean towards keeping them in a place that gets at least 6 hours of sun a day, rather than keeping them in the shade.

Final Thoughts

You can take the winter sown method and use it in so many ways.  I’m so pleased with the initiative that Erica took to see what she could do to get a start on spring planting.  That’s the attitude we all need as gardeners.

There are lots of different ways to do things.  But always keeping Nature’s principles in mind will always get you the best results.

Consider air circulation and sunlight in every aspect of your gardening.


Related Posts:

 Wintersown-Answer to questions about seeds and transplanting

You Can Plant in December

Looking at Winter Sown Seedling and the Garden

Seed Starting – Another Variation of Winter Sown

Winter Sown – Another Plus

Transplanting Root Crop Seedling

Wintersown and Garden Report – Radishes – Lettuce – Spinach

Seed Starting – It’s Easy Even with Less than Perfect Conditions

Winter Sowing – It Begins and Vegetable Tidbits

Seed Starting – The Easy Wintersown Way


All content including photos are copyrighted by  All Rights Reserved.


  • Theresa, I’m so glad you’ve mentioned (in this post and others on winter sowing) the idea of leaving the warm weather seed jugs inside until they germinate, then moving them outside. I’ve never tried this before. I planted some tomato and herb seeds about five days ago and have them on a heat mat in a spare room. I’m sure this will hasten their germination! Thanks for all your wonderful gardening ideas!

  • Well done Erica! It sounds like she is doing great. Thanks for sharing what others are doing, Theresa.

  • Sue, glad you’ve got your tomato and herb seeds ready to germinate. Moving them outside after germination, as I outlined in the post, really makes things easier. Less tending that way.

    Thanks for joining in Sandra. I always thinks it helps everyone to know what other gardeners are doing.
    Even if we don’t want to do things exactly that way it stimulates ideas of our own.

    Diane, it’s wonderful to hear from you! I know you’ve had your hands full with shipping seed and getting ready for the growing season, but I’ve missed you!

    I was delighted to hear from your daughter, Megan, and learn that she’s read the book and subscribed to TMG. It’s so great that she’s now an official partner in your business!

    Thanks for taking the time to comment Diane. Again, it’s wonderful hearing from you and learning that you are loving the book. If you have questions or additional comments you know I’d be so pleased to hear them.


    PS to all readers: If you haven’t already, check out what Diane has to offer at
    Diane is one of the last of small growers.(She’s in Utah.) Unique heirloom tomatoes are one of her specialties. She has a nice selection of annuals, perennials, vegetables, and herbs.

    She ships quickly so you still have time to order. And I can personally guarantee, you’ll never find anyone any nicer to deal with.

    Check out her site and see what she has to offer while you’re still at the computer. You’ve still got time to raise some great tomatoes from seed!

  • Theresa, you’ll love this…I am starting lavender plants from cuttings and I used my winter sown jugs for this. It seems to be working beautifully so far with a nice mini greenhouse effect. I have the hope of planting a huge lavender field so I can expand my farmer’s market offerings. If this works, then I will be able to keep adding more and lavender plants to my new field! Yay for winter sown!!! It worked beautifully for seeds and now on to propagating cuttings!
    Happy Easter!

  • Great idea Suzanne! I’m sure you’ll have much success. Remember to that you can grow lavender from seed. (Wintersown, of course.) 🙂
    Let me know how everything works out.

  • Theresa,
    After reading your last post I have some concern about my potatoes. As you know I am doing 100% wood chips for gardening, they are decomposing nicely after being on the ground 1 1/2 years. I followed the promoter of the wood chip method and his timing of planting potatoes. Paul Gautschi promotes planting and harvesting potatoes on exactly the same day. That means he promotes planting potatoes in the fall. My question is this, I planted potatoes last fall and no sign of growth yet, when do I know the potatoes are or are not going to come up? I have had some concern about planting potatoes in the fall. You so kindly shared about the progress of your produce and said potatoes are up about 2 inches. I know it is early and we had a hard frost just this morning I am zone 5-6. Should I have concern about the potatoes coming up? What is your opinion. As always you are so informative and kind to share your wisdom and experiences.
    Thanks Steve

  • Hi Steve,
    I don’t remember your telling me where you are located, but probably you are a bit colder than we are here in Virginia. And – even then, many of my potatoes are still not up yet. Some parts of the garden are colder than other parts. But when they’re ready, you’ll go out one morning and there they’ll be.

    A week or so ago, I was digging around in one spot and accidentally uncovered some potatoes. They looked great and had just started to sprout. They still have not come up yet, but they will.

    The earth (and the potato) knows the right time. So just be patient. More than likely you have nothing to worry about. If they are not up by June, I might want to take a peak and see what’s going on under there. 🙂

  • Theresa,
    Thanks for your reassurance you always seem to have the answers. I guess that is what 36 years experience will do for a person. By the way I live in Missouri north of Kansas City. I hope the potatoes don’t play with my emotions till June.
    Thanks again

  • An update on how everything shook out. I ended up leaving the tops on everything and left them in full sun, but I did move the tomatoes to partial shade, just for the weekend of high temps. Everything faired just fine. Until Tuesday when it got down to 28 and the poor little tomatoes collasped. I think there are still ungerminated seeds in the jug, so I will just let it keep going. Everything else survived the freeze with the jug tops on. In hind sight I probably should have thrown a blanket on everything or moved the fragile little tomatoes inside for the freeze. I will start propping the tops open for the necessary air circulation and probably take them off all together next week. Thanks for all of your insight and knowledge!!

  • Thanks for the update Erica. Glad almost everything made it.
    Tomatoes don’t like it below 40, and when it hits 32 you can know you’ll loose them.
    Your idea about moving the tomatoes inside for the freeze is a good one.
    Have a great season!

Leave a Comment