Plant Residue

What are You Doing with Finished Plants?

I received an email recently from a reader telling me she’s taking down  plants of veggies that are finished.

Immediately, I wondered what she was doing with the residue. 

Hopefully she was leaving it in her garden.

Why Leave it in the Garden?

For as long as I’ve gardened (44 years) I’ve always cut and dropped all finished plant material back onto the garden. It seemed an obvious way to help replenish the soil. After all that’s what nature does. 

But it was not until I read the book by noted soil scientist, Robert Parnes that I realized even more how important organic residues are. 

Take Advantage of what a Noted Soil Scientist Learned over the Years

I’ve mentioned soil scientist Robert Parnes in several of my posts. He ran the soil testing facility at Wood End Laboratory in Maine in the 1980s. The Lab’s specialty then was to offer recommendations for organic and/or synthetic fertilizers.

His conclusion after many years of making recommendations for fertilizers to what must have been thousands of farmers and gardeners, may surprise you.

It  creates a tendency to ignore (and thus belittle) the far more important value of organic residues. 

Understand fully what he’s saying here: Using  organic residues is one of the most important things you can do for your garden. Grasping this important part of working with nature can make a big difference in how successful you’ll be.

After all the information he gives on many “fertilizers” in his book he advises that if the conditions (for the various fertilizers) are difficult to keep in mind —simply “consider organic residues.”  

It has been his finding that the energy from organic residues is required to maintain soil fertility. And he states “there is no substitute”.   

 “—the major emphasis for good soil management should be on recycling organic residues, —”Robert Parnes

Organic Residues are More Beneficial Than Fully Decayed Compost

Allowing organic residues to decay in your garden is more beneficial than putting it in a compost pile to totally decay. The greater benefit comes from allowing it to decay in your garden. 

That’s a well kept secret since compost and all the things that can be sold regarding it’s making and such are widely promoted.

Nothing wrong with using compost — but just know that the greater benefit is from organic residues decaying in the garden.

Final Thoughts

If you’re a gardener who objects to how the residue of finished plants in the garden looks, cover it with straw or whatever you use for mulch.

Mr. Parnes’ book is  freely available to the public under a creative commons license. (He maintains copyright, but you can read for free.)

Suggested Related Reading:

https://tendingmygarden.com/mulching-weeds-annuals-crop-residue-to-the-rescue/

https://tendingmygarden.com/organic-residues-the-needed-energy-for-soil-fertility/

__________

All content including photos is copyright by TendingMyGarden.com. All Rights Reserved.

15 Comments

  • How can I plant cover crops in the mess of vines and plants when I cut down the finished growth?

  • Hi Theresa,

    I’ve started a letter to you but never got to finish it. I appreciate this post but I have a problem. My zucchini and yellow squash plants did great this summer but recently we’re attacked by a worm and the fruit is either dying or is full of worms. I realize I will have to dispose of this plant rather than cut and drop it on the garden, am I right?
    I’ll definitely cut and drop the field peas, tomato plants, peppers and basil when the time comes.

    Susan L.

  • Thanks for this Theresa! I’m trying this for the first time in my life. I’ve always “tidied up” the garden and removed everything. I’ve been gardening as long as you have. I’m nervous about this. Haha. My area only gets 12″ or less of moisture per year and so it can be a bear to get things to decompose. I’m going to start leaving pretty much everything this year and see how it goes and if it’s just too much, I will remove some of the debris in subsequent years. I have a very small lot and so there’s not a lot of room to pile debris for composting, etc. (I use a tumbler for scraps). One thing I have noticed already is how the earth worm population has increased with just leaving some debris already. I have to be careful with any fruits or vegetables (they have to go in the tumbler) because the Roly Poly bugs are rampant here and they get a taste for those things and then move on to the living things I don’t want them to eat. Anyway, thanks again. Sure hope you are doing better.

  • My paths are only 18″, and the garden beds 36″. I have a fairly small garden, 35×45′. I didn’t want to have 50/50 paths and beds. I remove the finished plants to the compost pile (although I understand why it would be superior to leave it in the beds), rake the straw and detritus onto the paths, then plant a cover. I cover that with straw, and then with tons of fall leaves. Perhaps more straw on top of that? So my paths end up being taller than my beds, or at least more solid. The garden beds are always covered with something: planted vegetables, straw, crop cover, leaves, etc.

  • Unless I see a plant disease, EVERYTHING from my garden goes right back into the garden. Let it rot! I loved to mix leaves, wood chips, and garden residue all together and mix it all in the soil The leaves come from from the trees at the edge of my property. I have a mulching mower. The wood chips come from the residue of the highway crews that recently (two years ago) cut the trees along the highway. Well over two years old now, the wood chips are. I also mix my kitchen scraps in there as well, all vegetarian. I try to keep it as organic as I can. I also grow cover crops and mix them in as well. All in all, it’s a “mixed” bag, pun intended.

    Don in Stafford, Virginia

  • Dear Mary, Rebecca, Susan, Rob D, Don, and Chris,
    Thank you for your EXCELLENT comments and questions.
    I consider them so important to this post that I want to dedicate another post to answer and comment on them.

    Might take me a while but I hope to get it up as soon as possible. However, I’ll wait a bit to see if others leave comments and questions so those can be included in my reply.
    Thank you again for taking time to leave your great questions and input!
    Theresa

  • Hiya Theresa!
    Yep, it’s getting to be that time of year already! Thanks to you, this will be my 4th year of chopping and dropping spent plants in my garden beds. Something that is making this process easier is this tool I got online https://www.walmart.com/ip/Fiskars-Forged-Grass-Shears-Black/20613407?classType=REGULAR&athbdg=L1100&from=/search
    It’s a combination of the best parts of heavy duty scissors and pruners. Very well made, no plastic parts. My grandson will be able to use these one day if he so desires.
    Being able to cut everything up in smaller pieces should speed up decomposition.

    Look forward to your follow up post.
    Take care and God bless,
    Harold

    Note from Theresa: With Harold’s permission I omitted part of his comment because I wanted to focus on it in a stand-alone post. You can read the rest of his comment and the post here: https://tendingmygarden.com/harolds-comment-and-2-things-to-consider/

  • Is it safe to use straw. As I understand it, crops, such as wheat, are sprayed with herbicide and that herbicide is retained in the byproducts of the plant, such as straw. Then that herbicide can be absorbed by the vegetables/fruits one grows, causing long term harm to the consumer…

  • Graham some farmers (I don’t know the percentage) do spray with glyphosate pre-harvest to speed drying time. At least that is what I’ve read.
    The family that has been bringing me my straw for 40 years does not.
    If straw is sprayed with glyphosate I for one would think it harmful and not use it.
    Hopefully readers will add this to their list of questions they need the answer to before they buy straw.

    Thanks for posting the question Graham. It’s an important one.
    Theresa

  • Thank you Theresa for summarising this information so well in this post.
    I’ll look forward to your replies to the other comments, especially to Mary Stella’s one: “How can I plant cover crops in the mess of vines and plants when I cut down the finished growth?”. I struggle with that too. I have my way of doing it now (and I think I know what your answer will be), but I want to know if I got it “right” 🙂

  • I’ve always heard to dispose of tomato, potato and raspberry clippings as they are more likely to harbor disease. What are your thoughts on this?

  • Wow! Here all this time I’m thinking I have to set up a proper compost bin, etc. I wish the rest of the gardening world would be talking about this. It makes life much easier! Thank you.

Leave a Comment