Residual Herbicides

Revisiting Residual Herbicides

Certain chemicals make it through the digestive tract of grazing animals and stay in their manure. Composting will not neutralize them as in days gone by. They’ll deform your plants and cause poor or non-existent yields. They remain in the soil for years. (Some sources say 4 to 10 years. And other sources say they’re next to impossible to neutralize.)

When you follow the links provided further down, information will be given to help you know what to look for and give you the best chance of avoiding having these chemicals end up in your garden.

There is nothing worse than spending months planning, preparing, planting, etc only to have the entire garden poisoned with these residual herbicides that you had no idea were there.

This Past July 13, a Reader Wrote the Following to me.

“About 5 years ago on the advice of a friend I put down equal amounts of Garden soil and steer manure to a spot I wished for a garden. 

Later I discovered it was way too much manure and ruined the soil. I tried again this year by putting in bargain garden soil, and again have failed to have any healthy veg, namely greenbeans, Zucchini,  summersquash, cucumber. 

My crops are not bright green in color and barely growing, and being eaten by insects. Do you think I can ammend the soil in this spot to ever have a healthy crop?”

In a later email my reader wrote, “ I was able to find out that at least the manure I previously applied was aged and sifted. Not sure how much that means but I’m hopeful that maybe it didn’t have those deadly chemicals.”

What It Means

Unfortunately manure being aged and sifted means nothing when it comes to these long lasting chemicals. 

About all it indicates is that someone knew manure should be aged.  They probably had no idea the manure contained poisons that would deform plants and cause poor or non-existent yields for years to come. 

What I Thought When I Read My Reader’s Email

Immediately, I thought residual herbicides.  They’re sometimes called “forever chemicals”. If this was the case (and I feel confident it was) — it was not the manure that ruined the garden but the herbicides that remained in the manure. 

The vegetables mentioned in my readers email (greenbeans, Zucchini,  summersquash, cucumber) are among those most affected by these long lasting herbicides. Some others include tomatoes, eggplant, spinach, raspberries, and peppers. The list is probably much longer.

Why I Don’t Think it was “just” the Manure

Too much manure (when free of these long lasting herbicides) might ruin a garden the first year, but most likely the soil would correct itself by the second year. And to help that along – organic materials could be laid on top of manure and soil.  (Soil life will pull it down into the soil.)

Regarding the Plants Being Eaten by Insects

Researchers have found that plants that are not healthy literally send out signals to attract pest insects. Of course, any gardener knows by observation the healthier your garden is – the less pests  you’ll have. 

Preparing a Garden for Best Results

I hasten to add that “putting down Garden soil” (which I assume was  purchased soil) with even herbicide-free manure is not the best way to start a garden if you want the best results. 

To prepare your garden to get the best results follow the instructions in my book. 

Or go to my home page and scroll down to “Organic Gardening – Follow my 3 Keys. to Successful Gardening.”

My Answer to my reader’s question: Do you think I can ammend the soil in this spot to ever have a healthy crop?”

It depends on how long the chemical will last.   But since we don’t know the chemical involved we don’t know how long that will take.

If the chemical were known it might be possible to find out from the company how long it will last in the soil.

From current information I see online there are now 10,000 of these chemicals. This source  states they “are the most persistent synthetic chemicals to date, they hardly degrade in the natural environment —“

Here’s What I Would Do In My Reader’s Situation

If it was possible I would prepare another section of the land for the garden. 

If it’s not possible I’d start adding organic materials to the poisoned site.  That’ll bring more soil life to the area to help clean it.  

Lay the various organic materials on top of the soil. As mentioned previously the soil life will eventually pull things into the soil.

Cover crops can also be planted.

Planting a Few Plants Each Year  that are Known to be Susceptible Will be Necessary to Test the Soil

Since it’s not known how long the chemicals will last, my reader will have to test every year. (I’d test in spring and fall.) 

Since it’s said that beans are most susceptible to these chemicals  they make  good test subjects.  Plant 6 or more beans. If the beans look healthy AFTER they develop the second and third set of leaves the soil may be ok. 

I would also plant a few different veggies and see what they do as well. If these plants are healthy you can proceed from there. 

More Information in Previous Previous Posts

Readers give details of their encounters with these forever chemicals and how their extension office knew nothing about the problem.  Informative.

Compost – Hay – Residual Herbicides – Extension Office Advice – A Reader’s Experience

The post linked to below explains how these chemicals may be used and how they can end up in products you outsource. 

It lists the main chemicals in the pyridine group of forever chemicals — when I wrote the post in 2011 and explains how they are usually used. 

Since 2011 more have been added.  The source that I previously mentioned  states there are 10,000! (I hope they mean brand names rather than additional chemicals but it doesn’t read that way.) Here’s the link again: https://chemtrust.org/pfas/ 

You’ll learn many things to look out for and get suggestions for “safer bet organic materials to use”.

Keep in mind that all the chemicals I’ve mentioned in the post can be in different brand-names. So reading the label on the chemical packaging is the only way you can know what chemical is in it.

Compost – Mulch – Residual Herbicides – What You Can Do About Them in Your Garden

The next one gives you a better understanding of residual herbicides and how they can easily end up in composts you source from various places.

Residual Herbicides in Composts – Part I

Next-information on bagged composted manure, field collected manure, horse manure, blood meal and bone meal, bagged mulch, loose mulch, wood chips, yard cuttings, leaves,  and ornamental grasses.

Residual Herbicides in Compost Part 2: On Grow Mix, Potting Mix, Compost, Manure, & Mulch

Next – lot of information to help in making your decision of whether or not you want to use compost or manures that you outsource.

Tells of a simple test to help you determine if compost or manure has chemicals in it that will be harmful to your plants.

Municipal-Compost – Manures – Should you use them?

Final Thoughts

I wish I could have had better news for my reader. The very fact that she is still trying to garden after 5 years of poor results shows her strong character.

Now that she has a better idea of what really happened, hopefully she’ll be able to select another spot. And even if it’s small, start again in ground that is not poisoned — as she continues to test the other site each year.

Please take advantage of all the posts I’ve written and gain the knowledge to help you keep these forever chemicals out of your garden – and your body. It’s worth the effort.

_______

All content including photos is copyright by TendingMyGarden.com. All Rights Reserved.

9 Comments

  • Hi Theresa! I pray you are feeling better!

    Oh boy, I have dealt with this chemical nightmare in my own garden as well. I put in a raised bed about 5 years ago. I bought a fortune’s worth of so-called “organic” raised bed soil. Nothing would grow. It was horrible. I tried everything. Even radishes would just pop up and turn yellow and red and die.

    Needless to say, I was very disappointed. But… I went to work amending the soil. I first paid for a soil test to see what I *could* do to help things out. Once I was able to know what I could actually do to help renew this soil, I went to work. Well, 5 years later and this season I am having a much better time. It’s not perfect yet, but it’s getting there.

    I was always suspicious that this “organic” raised bed soil was not organic. I’d never seen anything like it. Time and patience is the key. And I highly recommend the soil test because if there’s chemicals on top of other deficiencies things will never get back to normal.

    Another thing I did was get some worm castings. They are expensive, but there are often earth worm eggs in the castings and the worms will get busy digesting these poisons as well. I have thousands of earth worms now.

    Thanks for this post. I hope your reader gets things figured out. That is such a frustrating situation.

  • Thanks for taking time to leave your input Rob! I appreciate it and I feel confident
    it will encourage my reader about whom I was writing.
    I have one more long overdue post to write and then I can give my garden report!! Yipee!
    Thanks again Rob.
    Theresa

  • Addendum to the Post—
    Just wanted to mention that this is a world wide problem in case readers outside the US may think it doesn’t apply to them. When the problem first came to light in about 1999 to 2,000 in the US — these
    chemicals were also causing a problem in New Zealand.
    So be aware wherever you are in the world.
    Theresa

  • We notice that your garden is covered with straw. How do you assure yourself that the straw is chemical free?

  • Theresa, thank you for collating all this information here. It’s very useful!
    I tried to do my homework and to ask what the straw I buy is sprayed with. I haven’t found a farmer to buy it direct from (no crop fields around me even now that I live in a rural area – there are pastures only, it looks like I would have no issues sourcing hay, but no sign of straw).
    Over the years I bought it from various companies that sell mulch for gardens, mainly pea straw because they think that’s what gardeners want these days… The very frustrating answer I usually get is something on the lines of: “We are not sure what the farmers spray, but nothing dangerous, don’t worry! It’s good quality straw, we’ve been selling it for years to gardeners without complaints.” I admit that I just left it there and forced myself to trust them because I need the straw and there are no other options available… so far I’ve been lucky and had no problems…
    I also go and get pine needles from the forest sometimes, but I feel uncomfortable even doing that: they are commercial forests and I know they get sprayed…. so far so good, but I’m not sure when I’m going to run out of luck.
    Honestly I’m working towards ‘mulch self-sufficiency’, but it’s going to take years!!!

  • I totally relate and understand all you experienced Giulia.
    Bottom line is — the best we can do is all we can do.
    Theresa

  • Great post, Theresa. We can’t trust anything anymore. Free or paid for, it’s hard to find clean products. You’re so right about knowing your source. We used to get free mushroom compost from the mushroom growers. Once I found out that they used manure from the race horses, I was done. The best ground cover that I have used is ground up trees – bark. Often times they will deliver it to you for free. I always ask what type of trees, but even pine trees have kept the water in ground and I’ve found mycorrhizae growing underneath. Some horse owners are very careful. Their gardens are lush!
    Thank you, Theresa, for all the great tips and keeping us mindful of the quality of our food. I’m so glad you are better!

  • Theresa, thank you so much for the abundant information and help. I was totally nieve about residual pesticides, manure and soil until I read all of the information. My garden improved somewhat this year as I continue to replenish my soil, and now with all of my new knowledge (thanks to you and your tendingmygarden news, I am confident that I will have an even better crop next season. I will continue to look forward to all of your posts.

Leave a Comment